What is AI Auditing and Why Does It Matter?

Written by Lara Miller | Apr 24, 2025 7:00:00 PM

Artificial Intelligence (AI) is no longer just a sci-fi buzzword — it's here, real, and transforming how businesses operate.

AI is everywhere, from chatbots that never sleep to algorithms that predict what you'll buy next. But with great power comes great responsibility. (Yes, I just quoted Spider-Man!) That's where internal auditors come in, using AI auditing frameworks to help organizations navigate the risks, ethics, and controls that come with this powerful technology.

Why should auditors care about AI?

Imagine being tasked with auditing a system that can think, learn, and adapt. Sounds intimidating, right? AI is a game-changer, but it also comes with risks — bias, data breaches, and even the dreaded “black box” problem, where no one knows how the AI made a decision. Internal auditors are the unsung heroes ensuring that AI is used ethically, securely, and effectively.

An AI auditing framework is like a roadmap for auditors, guiding them through the complexities of AI. Whether you’re a seasoned pro or a newbie, a framework can help you navigate the risks, governance, and controls of AI systems.

The key components of an AI audit framework

The framework should be divided into three main domains: Governance, Management, and Internal Audit. Think of it as a three-course meal for AI auditing:

Governance: This is the appetizer. It’s all about setting the tone at the top. Does the organization have an AI strategy? Are ethical and legal considerations built into it? Governance ensures that AI aligns with your institution’s values and goals.

Related: A Guide to Governance for Financial Institutions

Management: The management team is the “main course” responsible for executing the AI strategy, designing internal controls, and monitoring risks — everything from data integrity to cybersecurity. Bonus points if they’ve set up a cross-functional AI leadership team, as teamwork is crucial for success.
Internal Audit: The dessert (who doesn’t love dessert?) is where auditors shine, providing assurance and advisory services. Whether it’s evaluating AI-related risks or ensuring compliance with laws, internal auditors are the final line of defense.

What are AI auditing challenges?

Auditing AI isn’t your typical day at the office. Here are a few unique challenges your institution may face and how to tackle them:

The Black Box Problem: AI can be a mystery, even to its creators. Auditors need to ask the tough questions: How does the AI make decisions? Is it explainable? If not, document the risks and push for transparency.
Bias and Ethics: AI can unintentionally discriminate. Auditors should ensure the organization tests for biases both before and after deployment. Remember, fairness isn’t optional — it’s essential to monitoring and mitigating risk.
Data, Data, Data: AI relies on data, but is your information accurate, secure, and private? Auditors should dive deep into governance and user access controls to ensure data protection.

How to get started

Feeling overwhelmed about creating an AI auditing framework? Here are some quick tips to kickstart your journey:

Ask the Big Questions: Start with simple inquiries, such as “How is AI being used in the organization?” and “What risks are we managing?”
Build Relationships: Talk to IT, data teams, and the C-suite about your AI auditing strategy. Collaboration is key.
Create an AI Inventory: Document where and how AI is being used within your institution and through vendors. This will be your go-to resource.
Focus on Training: AI is evolving fast, and so should your skills. Invest in employee training to stay ahead of the curve.

AI and the future of audits

AI is here to stay, and it’s only getting smarter. Institutions that embrace AI responsibly will thrive, while those that ignore the risks could face consequences. Internal auditors play a critical role in ensuring that AI is a force for good.

An AI auditing framework isn’t just a guide — it's a secret weapon, helping you tackle risks, ensure compliance, and add value to your organization. So, go ahead — dive into the world of AI auditing. Who knows? You might just become the AI audit hero your organization needs.

Want to elevate your findings management?

Learn best practices and strategies for leveraging findings as a risk management tool.

View full post